Wednesday, July 17, 2013

The Scottish Referendum

I first heard about the Scottish Referendum while watching RTÉ a few months back. My first feelings were of elation, then hope for future implications this legislation could have on Norther Ireland. For those of you who don't know, the referendum is a piece of legislation that puts the question of Scottish independence from England to a vote in September of 2014. There is a lot that is unclear to me about the referendum, not to mention the workings of Scottish government to begin with, and I am doing some research to try and understand it all.
Everything looks the same! Cite

I was always a bit useless at government and political science; too many rules and regulations. So I was excited to see a lecture offered from Stanford Continuing Studies by Robert Bartlett about the relationship between Scotland and England and the origins of the referendum found in the Middle Ages. Best of all, it was a free lecture.

A little about Mr. Barlett: A professor of medieval history at the University of Saint Andrew in Scotland, and has written several books and texts in his area of expertise. He is a great speaker, and his lecture was chocked full of typical English wit. Although his lecture was about political relations from almost thousand years ago, he was easily able to tie in medieval events with the present.

At first, it was unclear if I would ever find out the origins of the referendum because the auditorium was damn near impossible to find. (It was in a basement. When a building has the name "auditorium" attached to it, one usually looks at ground level instead of underneath it.) Thank heaven I ran into a lovely woman with a Liverpool accent who could read a map. Specifically, she could read the portion of the map I had trouble with, which was labeled "Basement." Andrew, Sam, and Jayde know how wonderfully clever I am at directions.

This is a freeway? Image Source
Moving right along, Mr. Bartlett started with a review of the late, prehistoric period and showing the boarder between Scotland and England as often varied throughout history. But what makes a nation is not completely defined by it's contours and lines, and as the professor would point out, nations come and go. However, the people remain, and though the Union of Crowns (in which James VI of Scotland became the new, James I of England and Ireland, as well) occurred in 1603 AD, we are still talking about the possibility of Scottish independence from Britain today.

Mr. Bartlett's book, link below
Some of the things that makes us still think of Scotland as a separate entity from Britain is that Scottish law, religion, and education are different than and just as powerful as that of it's British counterpart. This wasn't an accident. Although there were previous kings, in 1124 David I made drastic changes to Scottish government and politics that set Scotland up as a rival and equal of England. This gave Scotland a firm base to become a political force among other medieval nations, such as England, and as Mr. Bartlett stated, "the Scots have the power, the institution, to resist."

Reasons for the union between Scotland and England are a bit too long for this post. If you are interested, however, Mr. Bartlett has some great books available on Amazon, and the UK Parliament website has an active history section that I will be exploring at great length myself. But back to the Northern Irish question, does the Scottish referendum set a precedent for Northern Ireland being given it's own right to choose? After listening to the lecture and talking with Mr. Barlett, who likened the idea of Northern Ireland gaining it's own referendum to "throwing gasoline and a lighted match," I'm not so sure. Where Scotland built itself on equal footing as a united nation, Ireland was a mosaic of smaller kingdoms with little unity to fight outside forces. This isn't an excuse for England keeping Northern Ireland during the 1916 revolution, but it makes sense as to why Ireland's many rebellions had not worked beforehand.

What this lecture really taught me was that I need to do a lot more research on politics and government in both Ireland and the United Kingdom. Though I have met many people that feel passionately about Northern Irish freedom one way or another, I do not have enough historical knowledge to make up my own mind. Two of the best things about the lecture were that it was well attended, there must have been over fifty people in the audience, and that it challenged my idea of what defines a nation. I would gladly listen and learn from Mr. Bartlett again.

"It is in truth not for glory, nor riches, nor honours, that we are fighting, but for freedom- for that alone, which no honest man gives up but with life itself." - Declaration of Arbroath, Scotland, April 6, 1320

No comments:

Post a Comment